New Episodes every Monday
Every week, Whitney & Melissa travel from state to state, covering unsolved cases in an attempt to gain public awareness and encourage positive movement in the case.
Nebraska : Chance Englebert
25 year old Chance Englebert took a walk to blow off some steam after a disagreement with his wife's family never to be seen again. A trail of surveillance footage and several unanswered calls are all that investigators have to go on.
What happened to Chance Englebert?
Montana : Jeannette “Charlie” Atwater
Jeanette "Charlie" Rene Atwater was more than a tragic headline; she was a vibrant soul, a loving mother of three, and a generous spirit who left an indelible mark on those around her. On January 16th, 2000, her story took a dark turn as she was found lifeless in the trunk of her burning car. Despite the tireless efforts of law enforcement, her murder remains unsolved, leaving behind a haunting question of who could have committed such a heinous act against a woman known for her warmth and kindness. With each passing year, the mystery deepens, but the memory of Charlie lives on, etched in the hearts of those who loved her, and in the plea for justice that echoes through the decades.
Anyone with information is encouraged to reach out to the Yellowstone County Cold Case Unit at (406) 869-3530.
Minnesota : Cassandra Rhines
Cassandra Rhines was a beautiful young woman who lived on the southwest side of Minneapolis. In June 1985, the then 19-year-old went missing after not showing up for her goddaughter’s birthday party. Her whereabouts would not be known for almost 30 years until her remains were discovered over 190 miles away.
What happened to Cassandra Rhines?
Michigan : Jessica Phelps
This week Melissa and Whitney dive into the tragic disappearance and murder of Jessica Phelps, a bright and spirited four-year-old girl who vanished from her home in Flint, Michigan, on July 1st, 1997. Despite extensive searches and public outcry, Jessica's whereabouts remained unknown for almost a year when her remains were found.
If you have any information about the murder of this little girl please contact Flint Police Department at (810) 237-6800.
Massachusetts : Rita Hester
Rita Hester was a vibrant stunning woman who loved big and lived large. She was an artist that was well known in the Allston community. Two days before her 35th birthday she was brutally murdered inside her apartment.
Who killed Rita Hester?
Maryland : Arlene Byrd & Antonio Smith
After a party, Arlene Byrd and Antonio Smith returned to his apartment where they were tortured and murdered.
What happened to Arlene & Antonio?
Maine : Ashley Ouellette
In the small, coastal town of Saco, Maine, the unsolved murder of 15-year-old Ashley Ouellette continues to haunt the community. Ashley, a once-rebellious teen on a path to recovery, was found strangled on Pine Point Road in 1999. Despite extensive investigations, law enforcement faces a 3.5-hour gap in Ashley's whereabouts and a lack of conclusive evidence. Ashley's family is still seeking answers.
Who killed Ashley Ouellette?
Louisiana : Nanette Krentel
In this episode, Melissa and Whitney discuss the unsolved murder case of Nanette Krentel from Lacombe, Louisiana. Nanette was a kind woman, devoted wife, and a retired school teacher. Despite the relatively safe location of her home, Nanette lived in fear due to various threats and disturbing incidents. She was eventually found dead in her home, which was purposely set ablaze. Despite numerous suspects and an unsatisfying investigation, Nanette's case remains unsolved.
Who killed Nanette Krentel?
Kentucky : Natasha Fugate Jones
Natasha Fugate Jones disappeared on an early May morning. The 31 year old mother of 2 boys left a note behind for her kids stating she would be home in a few days. She never returned.
Where is Natasha Jones?
Kansas : Alonzo Brooks
In this episode of "Navigating Advocacy," Melissa & Whitney dive into the mysterious case of Alonzo Brooks, a man who tragically vanished from a party in La Cygne, Kansas. Join us as we uncover the harrowing details of his disappearance, the extensive search efforts, and the shocking developments that led to the reopening of his case after 15 long years.
Iowa : Donna Sue Davis
The quaint town of Sioux City, Iowa was changed on July 10, 1955, when 21 month old Donna Sue Davis was taken from her crib into the summer night. A community rallied together to search for the "Darling of the Neighborhood" but turned up empty handed. The following day, a farmer and his wife would find Donna Sue.
Who killed Donna Sue Davis?
Indiana : Jill Behrman
Join Melissa and Whitney this week as they discuss the chilling mystery surrounding Jill Behrman's disappearance and tragic death. Uncover the dark secrets, shocking confessions, and controversial trial that cast doubt on the justice served. Join us in navigating through the twists and turns of Jill's story, shedding light on the unresolved questions that linger over this tragic case.
Illinois : Damien Henderson
Damien Henderson's unsolved murder. An athlete with a quiet life, Damien's mysterious death prompts more questions than answers. The gentle giant father of two daughters was seeking help to improve his life after a few poor decisions.
Help further the case by contacting Champaign Police at 217-351-4545 or anonymously through Crime Stoppers at 217-373-8477.
Idaho : Thomas Sherwood
September 3, 2000, law enforcement were called to the Sherwood residence because Stephanie Sherwood had found her husband, Thomas deceased. When they arrived, the scene was described as a possible suicide. Investigations later revealed that this may not be the case.
What happened to Thomas Sherwood?
Hawaii : Jubiliee “Maile” Lum
Jubilee "Mailee" Lum was found deceased in August 1999 behind a well known florist shop in Honolulu, Hawaii. The 21 year old was planning her future with her fiance, attending classes and was 4 months pregnant.
Who killed Maile?
Georgia : Brian Samples
Brian Lorenzo Samples, born in 1976, was a master carpenter, musician, and devout Christian from Buford, Georgia. Despite drug dependency struggles, he completed a rehabilitation program in East Dublin in 2019. Brian went missing on July 6, 2019, and was last seen at a Red Carpet Inn. His family, suspecting foul play due to shady acquaintances and a recent insurance check, initiated a search. Three months later, remains found behind the motel were identified as Brian's.
What happened to Brian Samples?
Florida : Bryan “Vladek” Hasel
Bryan "Vladek" Hasel is a kind, sensitive, and loving brother who disappeared in November 2021. His family is desperately trying to find him.
Where is Vlad?
Delaware : Susan Ledyard
Susan Ledyard, a passionate educator with a penchant for literature and human rights, met a tragic end on July 23rd, 2019. Found lifeless in the Brandywine River just a mile from her home, Susan's mysterious last night raises troubling questions. As her Fitbit recorded activity until 7 am, authorities seek answers to the gaps in her whereabouts between 3 am and 7 am.
Susan's husband, Ben Ledyard, provided a puzzling account of that fateful night, claiming unawareness of her disappearance until authorities arrived.
Connecticut : Leah Ulbrich
Leah Baskins Ulrich was a dedicated mother from Hartford, Connecticut. In 1995, she was murdered in a horrifying incident. Despite investigations, the case remains unsolved. . Over the years, many witnesses came forward and potential suspects emerged, including a man with a criminal history of assaults on women. Despite renewed interest in 2019, technological advancements yielded no breakthroughs. Leah's children, now adults, advocate for justice, keeping their mother's memory alive. Law enforcement is seeking information, offering a $50,000 reward.
Colorado : Candace Hiltz
Candace, a promising 17-year-old with dreams of becoming a Supreme Court justice. Her life, however, takes a tragic turn on August 15, 2006, when she is brutally murdered in her home. The investigation unveils unsettling details, from a contentious encounter with law enforcement to the discovery of her beloved dog's murder, pointing to a disturbing sequence of events.They scrutinize the flawed investigation that initially focused on Candace's brother, James, who battles severe mental illness. The plot thickens with the shocking revelation of a police officer's misconduct. Who killed Candace Hiltz? Why did her family dog suffer a similar fate? And what secrets lie within the evidence mishandled by a law enforcement officer?